Abdalla et al. proposed a gateway-oriented password-based authenticated key exchange (GPAKE) protocol among a client, a gateway, and an authentication server, where a password is only shared between the client and the authentication server. The goal of their scheme is to securely establish a session key between the client and the gateway by the help of the authentication server without revealing any information on the password to the gateway. Recently, Byun et al. showed that Abdalla et al.'s GPAKE is insecure against undetectable on-line password guessing attacks. They also proposed a modified version to overcome the attacks. In this letter, we point out that Byun et al.'s modified GPAKE protocol is still insecure against the same attacks. We then make a suggestion for improvement.
Abdalla et al. proposed a gateway-oriented password-based authenticated key exchange (GPAKE) protocol among a client, a gateway, and an authentication server, where a password is only shared between the client and the authentication server. The goal of their scheme is to securely establish a session key between the client and the gateway by the help of the authentication server without revealing any information on the password to the gateway. Recently, Byun et al. showed that Abdalla et al.'s GPAKE is insecure against undetectable on-line password guessing attacks. They also proposed a modified version to overcome the attacks. In this letter, we point out that Byun et al.'s modified GPAKE protocol is still insecure against the same attacks. We then make a suggestion for improvement.